The course · Undertone · Lesson 4 of 6 · 21 min

Light or deep is one reading, warm or cool another

After this lesson you can read depth and lean as two separate answers. You can also name the six depth steps and say why the Monk scale gives depth but never a lean.

Black-and-white photo of a woman with straight dark hair and bangs, looking down with a faint smile and both hands at the front of her top, a second woman smiling behind her, and a laptop edge at the bottom of the frame

Ruth has fair skin that leans warm, and Keisha has deep skin that leans cool.

Ruth and Keisha each hold white paper beside the cheek in even daylight. Ruth's cheek is light and leans toward yellow. Keisha's is deep and leans toward pink. If depth and lean matched, a deep skin would always lean warm. Keisha shows that they do not.

Depth is how light or deep the skin is, and it is a reading apart from the lean.

A skin has a depth and a lean, and each comes from its own reading. Depth is the lightness of the skin. Undertone is the lean, a warm, cool or neutral hue. Neither reading gives you the other, so each is named on its own.

Depth falls into six steps by the skin's lightness, from step 1 at L* 70 and above to step 6 below L* 38.

The steps are bands of L*: 70 and above, 64 to 70, 57 to 64, 48 to 57, 38 to 48, and below 38. They carry no hue. Step 1 is the lightest and step 6 is the deepest. The bands are the method's own, and each one sits beside a Monk label for reference.

The Monk scale describes tone, not lean, and Google's own words say so.

Google describes its scale as designed for development and evaluation of technology while representing a broader range of skin tones. The scale has ten levels from light to dark. A tone scale can place a skin in depth, but it cannot place the lean. A deep skin can still lean cool.

Depth cannot set the lean, because lightness and hue are separate numbers in CIELAB.

Depth uses lightness. The lean uses hue, measured as an angle from neutral at 57 degrees. Chroma, the strength of the color, is a third number. Changing one does not change the others, so a deep skin can sit anywhere on the lean line, and so can a light one.

Ruth at step 1 reads one and a half steps warm, and Keisha at step 5 reads one and a half steps cool.

Say Ruth's cheek reads L* 72 at hue 66, and Keisha's reads L* 42 at hue 48. Ruth's lightness is 70 or above, so she is depth step 1. Keisha's lies between 38 and 48, so she is step 5. For lean, Ruth's 66 minus 57 is 9 degrees, 1.5 steps warm, and Keisha's 48 minus 57 is minus 9, 1.5 steps cool.

The method writes the depth step and the lean on separate lines, and names the lean last.

The depth step comes from the lightness reading and is kept whatever the lean turns out to be. The lean is named only once the drape confirms it, on its own line. A deep client is then never told that her depth is her lean.

Figure

Each square is one typical skin at one depth step and one lean. Steps run from 1 (light) to 6 (deep), and each lean is one step cool, neutral or warm of 57 degrees. Lightness falls as depth rises, while the lean moves the hue alone. In grays the squares differ only by lightness, so depth shows and the lean does not; in color, the warm column leans toward yellow.

Depth step 1, cool lean
Depth step 1, neutral lean
Depth step 1, warm lean
Depth step 2, cool lean
Depth step 2, neutral lean
Depth step 2, warm lean
Depth step 3, cool lean
Depth step 3, neutral lean
Depth step 3, warm lean
Depth step 4, cool lean
Depth step 4, neutral lean
Depth step 4, warm lean
Depth step 5, cool lean
Depth step 5, neutral lean
Depth step 5, warm lean
Depth step 6, cool lean
Depth step 6, neutral lean
Depth step 6, warm lean

In their words

“This scale was designed to be easy-to-use for development and evaluation of technology while representing a broader range of skin tones.”

Google, Improving skin tone representation across Google, blog post

Check

Keisha has deep skin. Does her depth decide that she leans warm?

Show the answer

B. No, she is deep and leans cool

Depth is one reading and the lean is another. Keisha's skin is deep, and her cheek still leans toward pink.

Practice

Skins G and H both read hue 63. G reads L* 74 and H reads L* 36. Which statement is correct?

Show the answer

A. G is step 1 and H is step 6, both one step warm

Lightness is the dimension that differs. 74 is 70 or above, so step 1, and 36 is under 38, so step 6. Hue 63 is 6 above 57, one step warm for both. Equal hue does not make them the same step.

Skins J and K both read L* 52. J reads hue 52 and K reads hue 62. Which statement is correct?

Show the answer

A. Both are step 4; J is about one step cool, K one step warm

Hue is the dimension that differs, and lightness is equal, so both sit in the 48 to 57 band, step 4. J is 5 below 57, about 0.8 steps cool, and K is 5 above, about 0.8 steps warm. Neither falls inside the neutral band.

A client with rich skin says she must be warm. Her cheek reads L* 40 at hue 50. What do you tell her?

Show the answer

C. Step 5, and one step cool, since richness is depth

Depth is lightness, and L* 40 is in the 38 to 48 band, step 5. The lean is hue: 50 minus 57 is minus 7 degrees, about 1.2 steps cool. Richness tells you the depth, not the hue.

A phone app places a client at Monk 9, and the same app says she is cool. What is the Monk part telling you?

Show the answer

A. Only her depth; the cool came from another reading

The Monk scale has ten levels of skin tone and does not encode warm, cool or olive undertone. So Monk 9 names a deep tone. The cool word has to come from a separate reading of the hue.

You have a depth step from L* 60 and a lean from a hue of 51, and the drape has not been run. How do you record them?

Show the answer

D. Step 3 on its own line, the lean only after the drape confirms

The depth step comes from lightness and is kept whatever the lean turns out to be. The lean is a proposal until the drape confirms it, and each goes on its own line. Depth does not wait for the drape.

Two clients are both called fair. One leans toward yellow and one toward pink. What does the word fair tell you about the lean?

Show the answer

B. Nothing, since fair names depth only

Fair describes how light the skin is. The lean is a separate reading, and fair skin can be warm or cool, as these two show. No lean follows from depth.

Case study 4

Imani has deep skin, and she is sure her undertone must be warm because her skin is so rich. Her corrected cheek reads L* 41 at a hue of 51 degrees.

Give her depth step and her lean, and say why depth does not settle the lean.

Show the worked answer

Step 1: depth comes from lightness, and L* 41 is in the 38 to 48 band, step 5. Step 2: the lean comes from hue, and 51 minus 57 is minus 6 degrees, one step cool. Step 3: richness is lightness, and it tells nothing about hue. Step 4: record step 5 and cool on separate lines, and confirm the lean in the drape before you name it to her.